Why Didn’t We Leave Afghanistan Before Now? A Fear That Presidents Could Not Ignore


It’s hardly exceptional to say that success for america in Afghanistan was by no means probably. For years, consultants, students, and officers have coalesced on a standard set of causes for failure—native grievances, political factionalism, corruption, Pakistani secure havens, and a deep-seated Afghan resistance to occupation. All are notoriously intractable.

The issue of fixing the course of the Afghan battle begs the query why america didn’t simply depart and curtail the expense. “The failure of American leaders—civilians and generals by means of three administrations, from the Pentagon to the State Division to Congress and the White Home—to develop and pursue a technique to finish the battle should be studied for generations,” learn the New York Instances editorial web page in February 2019.
[time-brightcove not-tgx=”true”]

I’ve met few People who disagree that after September 11, 2001 we have been proper to go in to Afghanistan, seek out al-Qaeda, and overthrow the Taliban. To the tip of 2019, Gallup and different credible public opinion polls discovered {that a} majority of People by no means believed that the U.S. determination to invade Afghanistan was a mistake. But, in my anecdotal expertise, most People additionally assume we must always have left a while after that.

So why didn’t we depart? To some extent, we didn’t perceive Afghanistan. The lightning toppling of the Taliban regime in 2001 defused early issues within the Bush administration that Afghanistan would change into a quagmire. The success of the surge in Iraq a number of years later inspired U.S. navy and civilian leaders within the Obama administration to assume that the Afghan democracy is likely to be enabled to face by itself.

One other argument is that U.S. generals and navy officers didn’t need to depart. There’s something to this, although maybe lower than meets the attention. At occasions, high-ranking navy officers put forth plans to strengthen Afghanistan, corresponding to for the 2009 surge or the Trump administration’s 2017 South Asia technique. At different occasions, they requested that withdrawal timelines be prolonged or eliminated, corresponding to when Taliban offensives endangered the democratic authorities in 2015 and 2016.

Such actions, a lot of which have been the pure and proper a part of the nationwide safety decision-making course of, raised the political prices for any president looking for to withdraw. If issues went unhealthy, the president might be accused of appearing towards the recommendation of the navy.

Learn extra: I Was Deeply Concerned in Battle in Afghanistan for Extra Than a Decade. Right here’s What We Should Study

However when attempting to grasp why we didn’t depart, the guts of the matter actually comes right down to terrorism and its home political implications. The overriding query in all coverage debates was what degree of terrorist menace would emerge if the democratic authorities in Afghanistan fell. Certainly, generals would have had no leg to face on with out the very actual and palpable terrorist menace.

The Sept.11 assaults ignited a concern that presidents couldn’t ignore. Beforehand a minor irritation, terrorism remodeled into an actual menace to america, with the potential to contain chemical, organic, or nuclear weapons.

Within the early years of the battle the political environment in america was charged with danger of one other assault on the homeland. All through 2002, varied Gallup polls confirmed 50–85 % of People fearful {that a} terrorist assault on america was probably. President Bush by no means thought of declaring victory and going residence. He, Powell, Rice, and Rumsfeld agreed that the important thing lesson of the 1990s in Afghanistan was that, by ignoring the nation after the autumn of the Soviet Union, america had allowed terrorism to fester.

The specter of terrorism declined throughout President Obama’s presidency, but he too couldn’t ignore it. Through the 2009 debate over whether or not to surge tens of 1000’s of troops to Afghanistan, Obama shelved any plans for withdrawal. In keeping with the huge variety of books and articles, at no level in the course of the debate, from early 2009 to the ultimate determination, was full withdrawal formally mentioned.

Solely after the surge and the loss of life of Osama bin Laden in 2011 did Obama lay out a plan to withdraw by the tip of his presidency. However then the Islamic State rose in Iraq in 2014 and the Taliban threatened to overthrow the Afghan democracy with its offensives in 2015 and 2016. The intelligence neighborhood assessed that if the drawdown went ahead on schedule, safety may deteriorate to the purpose that terrorist teams may kind a secure haven in Afghanistan. With that backdrop, Obama accepted, with revisions, the requests of his generals and Protection Division to remain in Afghanistan.

The identical destiny befell President Donald Trump, by far the U.S. president most disgusted with Afghanistan. He too declared all U.S. forces would depart, solely to reverse course. He succeeded in lowering forces to the bottom quantity since U.S. troops arrived, however even the diminishing menace of terrorism dissuaded him from fulfilling his want to get out.

In one other place and time, home strain may need compelled a president to withdraw a lot earlier. Afghanistan by no means curried that sort of opposition. Presidents confronted little fashionable opposition to staying, nonetheless confused People have been by the battle. Not so with leaving. A president needed to fear about political blowback to an assault on the homeland. Leaving was extra politically harmful than staying.

Solely President Biden really managed to finish the battle for America. One thing have to be stated for his longstanding distaste for the battle. But we are able to additionally see how the context had modified. The shadow of Sept.11 was receding, lastly. The Islamic State had been defeated and its chief, Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, killed. Within the Pentagon, concern of terrorism had been eclipsed by concern for the nice energy competitors towards China and Russia. As vital, the COVID-19 pandemic was an unlimited new menace and ushered in new financial challenges.

It was not cheap to imagine that terrorism demanded that america fear about Afghanistan. In Biden’s phrases in April 2021, “We went to battle in Afghanistan due to a horrific assault that occurred 20 years in the past. That can’t clarify why we must always stay.”

The tragedy of Afghanistan is that success was unlikely and getting out was troublesome. There was no simple method out. Our battle in Afghanistan is maybe higher seen as a trial to be endured than a alternative. That’s not to absolve leaders from the numerous errors that have been made. It’s to have a practical understanding of what the fears of America as a folks wrought.